Why Do Search Engines Hate Real Estate Sites?

Posted Apr 26, 2007 @ 6:01 pm, Viewed by 927 Visitors, Read 952 Times.
If you have a real estate website and have studied the search engines you are probably aware that se's are not thrilled with the multitude of real estate websites that they have to sift through for their search engine index.  I don't think our industry is treated fairly and with a true knowledge of our business practices.

I realize that there are many, many real estate websites and some use duplicate content and others use shady seo practices.  Many real estate agents don't know about seo at all and many that do cannot afford to hire professionals.  Some go out on their own and learn some blackhat methods such as hidden text, cloaking and keyword spamming.  They might not truly realize these are frowned upon by the search engines and can cause more harm than good. 

Then there are completely clueless agents that actually pay for blackhat seo without knowing it (until their sites get banned).  I feel sorry for them because I realize that not everyone has an interest in seo and general website maintenance like some of us do.  They find a so-called seo expert and shell out the cash for questionable tactics.

The SE's Just Don't Understand Real Estate


This was evident to me by a remark that a respected search engine pro made when doing a manual check of a real estate website at a conference.  He was referring to a real estate website linking out to an "unrelated" link source, a mortgage company!  Without mortgage companies there would be no real estate sales.  We just got an in-house mortgage company in my office.  Years ago my broker (at the time) was a partner with a mortgage company and we were trained on taking mortgage applications.  Real estate and mortgage companies unrelated?  Doesn't that tell you something about the se's not understanding our business?

Peer to Peer Linking

On the REW Forum there was a recent challenge of "to keep state directory pages or dump them"?  On one side of the fence are the members that feel linking from a site to agents in other states is unnatural and serves no purpose other than to unnaturally inflate incoming links.  On the other side are agents that truly feel they are offering a service on their sites to visitors that may be thinking about buying a second home or actually moving out of state.  They are setting up these state pages as a "referral" source, providing one or more agent's website with local MLS search.

Well, then those links should have a "no follow" to truly serve that purpose - in one se's opinion.  I disagree.  Why can't we pass on our votes and receive votes to our sites by creating a true referral network?  What is so wrong and what is really unnatural about it?  Agents are taught to network.  Again, se's don't understand real estate.

Real Estate Is Not Just Local

Real estate is not always local.  I worked with two relocating clients recently.  They came from other states to move to Illinois.  Was my website the catalyst for this?  Yes, although there was no referral involved.  These people did their own research and even bypassed agents they were working with but were not happy with.  In one case, the buyer started her search in a different area and found one of the areas I work in (via my top positioned website), and called me directly as it was a distance from where her other agent was showing her properties.

However, I do notice I get "hits" from other agent's sites that I've linked from.  I'm not sure whether these are other agents checking things out or true potential buyers, but there is activity.  In fact, I have personally used my own state pages to search for properties in states I might consider buying a property in.  I used my referral partners to search the MLS in different states.  I did not use a search engine, I started with my own state page partners.  If I do decide to purchase a 2nd home in Arizona or any other state, I will use one of my partners that I have gotten to know through my peer to peer exchanges.

Since I used my own state pages to search properties in different states, then I feel it is logical to offer this to visitors to my site.  Why force them to do a search on an se when I can provide them with similar information from my own site?  The older my sites are, the more traffic they receive.  I want visitors to bookmark my site and feel it's worthwhile enough to come back to.  So I like to offer as much information as possible.  I can earn money selling local real estate or by referring out to an agent in another state or country.  Why do we have to worry about offering this kind of non-local information on our websites?

Chicago suburbs real estate

Specializing in the Southwest Suburbs including Tinley Park real estate.  Search for Orland Park homes for sale.

  • Rate this Post!
  • Print

14 Responses to “Why Do Search Engines Hate Real Estate Sites?”

Great article Judyo

Posted 3 years ago

I love it and it bothers heck out of me one would consider a mortgage company an unrelated link. I've been thinking about trying to add contextual links on some of my pages with other local businesses such as interior designers, home stagers or local businesses with the also adding links on their websites to me for the sake of having more local authority in Google's eyes. But crap, this post seems to say that would not necessarily be viewed positively..... Thoughts Morgan? One thing I have noticed as I was looking for some locals to link with based on this article, http://www.advancedaccess.com/marketing/marketing292.htm, hardly any businesses have websites#!#@!!! Also I'm concerned if I followed any of this strategy that I'd be losing out with my PR3 & 4 pages linking to PR1 pages--or maybe that is irrelevant now.... Thoughts on all the above?

Posted 3 years ago

Thanks Morgan. Jay, I think you'd be safe with local links. That's what G is trying to tell us, stay local. I don't agree that we should only have to focus on local areas since real estate is truly worldwide. I do agree with you that most local businesses do not have websites in my area. A question: I'm wondering if that live AA link is doing this post any good?

Posted 3 years ago

Feel free to delete it, Judyo. Sorry.

Posted 3 years ago

Jay, I don't want to delete your post - just an fyi. Whenever you put in a link (especially if it isn't to one of your own sites that you want a little link love to), delete the http and the www or put spaces between them and use "dot com."

Posted 3 years ago

Gotcha and agreed!

Posted 3 years ago

I agree with your reasoning wholeheatedly with what you are saying and I think you give an excellent explanation as to how and why you can benefit from these pages.

Posted 3 years ago

Judy - this was a great post! Thank you for telling our story. Funny, I did the same thing when one of our friends was moving to Texas; I went to my Texas referral page first as I had already established a relationship with someone. And, when we were looking for a realtor in another state, we didn't have any reciprocal links for the area, so I went to google to find one. She's now my only referral partner for that state. So, it works both ways actually.

Posted 3 years ago

Great article Judy, although I don't believe G hates real estate websites in general. I think they are going to spank the spammy (is that a word?) sites, many of which probably didn't deserve the ranking they had. There will always be reciprocal linking, and if we go beyond just those state pages like many of us are doing I think G will recognize that. Content rich websites with a lot of original content will naturally have reciprocal links and why not break it down with state pages. Those pages just need to be more than a list of links.

Posted 3 years ago

Thanks Ryan. Donna, if I didn't use my own pages I would question their value. But I use them myself (and you used your's) so why shouldn't they be helpful to others? Dennis, I agree that spammy sites should be demoted by the search engines. That was where I was trying to go with the first part of this post although it does seem a bit disjointed from the rest of the article.

Posted 3 years ago

I definitely think they are useful to others. We live in a highly mobile area -- people are always coming and going to this state (Florida). Plus, I wouldn't put one up if I hadn't already checked it out to ensure the quality.

Posted 3 years ago
photo SVRPaul

Great Post JudyO!

Posted 3 years ago
photo Sam Chapman

Judy - your comment about real estate not being local is right on. I have had out of state real estate agents contact me for referrals because they found my site and liked the content. Heck, I just called you a few days ago to send you a referral - and all because you were an early part of my real estate agent network on my website!

Posted 2 years ago
photo Mike Dammann

I do agree, I think that real estate has been singled out for a couple of years now by Google.

Posted 2 years ago
REW Blogs User Stats
Currently Online Users: 1
Total Users: 2,389
Entries: 7,605
Unique Views: 6,449,128
Total Views: 6,786,934
Total Comments: 9,372
Total REW Points: 510
judyo

judyo Judy Orr is in her 24th year as a REALTOR® in the southwest & near west Chicago suburbs. Judy mainly works in southwest Chicago, southwest & near west Cook County and northeast Will County. Read More

Related Posts
This User's Stats
Blog Entries: 57
Average Blog Rating: 2
Unique Views: 36,129
Total Views: 37,624
Comments Posted: 240
Comments Received: 170
REW Points: 0
Friends
  • Carolyn Gjerde-Tu
  • Dennis Pease
  • Eric Blackwell
  • James Boyer
  • Jennifer Mackay
  • John Sabia
  • Ken Smith
  • Lipply
  • Malok
  • MARK Z
  • Morgan Carey
  • Ryan Ward
  • san-diego-county
  • SEO Nick
  • Spoken Gently
  • SVRPaul
  • thataway61
Listed In