Art Foundry at Atlantic Station
Posted May 17, 2007 @ 9:25 pm, Viewed by 1488 Visitors, Read 1539 Times.I have a client who has a condo in Midtown Atlanta who just received her new tax bill with an amazing assessment of property value. Her condo is located in the Art Foundry at Atlantic Station. We have had the condo on the market for almost a year minus the holiday season at the end of 2006. Somehow the city of Atlanta, in its infinite wisdom, has appraised the property for far more than the actual value of the property. So, the statistics for this entry will be used for a few things; some of these statistics will be used to argue the true value of the property with the city and these statistics will also be used to reevaluate the list price for the condo - even lower. At one point we had this one bedroom one bathroom condo listed for sale for $235,000. It is currently listed for $220,000. The tax assessment came in at $238,000. Can someone please tell me what the tax assessors are thinking? Here we have a condo sitting on the market for almost a year for less than the assessed value. Everyone knows that assessed value in Atlanta is almost always lower than market value and here we have the city assessing this property for a price that it clearly is not worth. Is this a problem with competence at the appraisers office or is the city systemically and artificially increasing the assessments to increase tax revenue to a city that is desperately in need of additional revenue? For some answers, let's take a closer look at some sales statistics for The Art Foundry at Atlantic Station. Specifically, one bedroom condos:
- Currently there are 25 1 bedroom condos for sale. The list price for all 25 of these condos ranges from a high price of $254,000 to a low price of $189,900.
- There is 1 additional condo pending sale for $189,900.
- 2 condos have sold in the last 30 days. They both sold for about $190,000.
- 0 additional properties sold in the month before that.
- 4 properties have sold in the last 3 months. High price $241,000, average price - $199,000
- There have been 8 sales in the last 6 months. Days on market - 4 months. Average price - $199,000.
- In the last year,17 condos have sold in The Art Foundry. The highest sold price is $241,000. The average sold price was $210,415.
- The absorption rate, based on the last three months of sales is 19 months. That means if no new properties come on the market it is projected to take 19 months to sell the units currently available. That is very high.
So, from this information, it is fairly easy to see that my clients condo is NOT worth $238,000. More than likely, the value is about $210,000. Add to this the fact that a brand new building right next door has just begun selling brand new condos at this price point and you can expect the value to drop even farther because of the additional supply. The fact that the city is assessing this property at that price is astounding. Now I need to leave my frustration here and report some specific sales to my client so that she can provide evidence to the city that they are over assessing her condo.
Ryan is a REALTOR® serving the Atlanta Real Estate Market including Alpharetta, Buckhead, Chastain Park, Dunwoody, East Cobb, Roswell, Sandy Springs, Milton and John's Creek.
Phone: (404) 630-3187
Atlanta Real Estate
ryan (@) ryanwardrealestate.com
8 Responses to Art Foundry at Atlantic Station
You should appeal the findings. It isn't that hard to do really...Not to long ago the entire board got into quite a bit of trouble and it looks like they are back to the same shenanigans that got them into trouble in the past. All you need are some comparables to present to them. Let me know if you need some help...
The City of Atlanta does not establish appraised value. Fulton County does. It's higher than FMV in many parts of the city because the County Tax Assessor's office is incompetent.
Fellas - the Fulton County Board of Assessors is responsible for the assessed value, not the City of Atlanta....please get your facts straight. Also, I have appealed my assessment successfully - you can do the same. Stop whining and do something about it.
Oops! sorry about writing Atlanta there guys. I was actually writing something else somewhere else and didn't edit my blog entry here correctly. It is definitely Fulton County who does this, not the city...I have actually helped three people appeal Fulton County on this issue as it is definitely a matter of competence, pressure from the cities to increase revenue and the fact that most homeowners are to apathetic to pursue the appeal process. You are correct atlanta dude. It is quite easy to get it corrected. You are however incorrect in your statement about whining about it. As a result of this one blog post, two people have appealed their assesment, which was the point. Whining about it is what people do that don't do something about it! Thanks for catching that guys. Total slip up on my part.
There are many interesting things about tax appraisals. Say the rental value of your condo is comment_body,000 and a Post or other major apartment unit rents for the same. Post etc. will pay less than half and perhaps as much as a fourth less in property taxes, per unit, as you.
My bid was just accepted for a foreclosed Art Foundary condo and I'll be closing in early 2/08. My experience with assessed valuation is that it is square footage and date biased. When a property is assessed, two components are calculated --- the real estate (lot) value and the improvement (built square footage) value. A building ;lot whould only have a land value, a house would have a land pluse improvemnt value. A condo has an assessed value for square footage and a vlue for location --- differentiation in location seldom accounts for whether a condo is on the sixth or 16th floor., it only accounts for the fact that it is in a hgih rise. Importantly, assessed values are calculated at a point in time --- when the condo is built. In the past two years condo prices have fallen. Their assesed values will remain the sme. there's a reason for this in that collected taxes are used for municipal budgets which need to be met whether the real estate market goes up or down. A respondent above recommended appealing the tax --- there's no chance that that wil work as a lowering of taxes on one unit will only open the door to lowering taxes on all the units. The best approach is not to appeal, but to sue. Get your day in court and just maybe enough attention could be brought to your case to reform relative valuations across the board. BTW I just bid for and got a oreclosed condo in Art Foundry. If i told you the sales price, you'd forget all about the txes you're paying and focus on how far the prices have fallen i the past two years.
February, Congrats on getting a great deal. We were able to get the county appaisers to adjust the value based on comparables. Just because there is a municipal budget does not mean that any government has the right to overcharge you for your taxes. They handle it on a case by case basis and they know that most will never bother to challenge their valuations so when someone challenges the value and come armed with facxts, they pretty much have to adjust the value.
REW Blogs User Stats
Currently Online Users:
1
Total Users:
1,665
Entries:
4,959
Unique Views:
2,281,813
Total Views:
2,356,011
Total Comments:
4,858
Welcome to my real estate blog! I will try to provide you with relevant and timely information about the Atlanta real estate market as well as information that you can use if you are in the market to buy or sell real estate. Read More
- This User's Stats
Rate this Post!
Share this Post
Print
Social Bookmarking
View My Listings
Contact Me
RSS Feed
Top Rated
REW Blogs RSS Feed
I too am wondering if this is some sort of scam by the city of Atlanta tax appraisers to raise more money for the bankrupt city. I live in Twelve Atlantic Station, and my Tax appraisal was ,000 above what I paid for it the same year. Usually the tax appraisal is about 20% below market value. When Twelve sold their condos they charged 2k per floor, so the exact unit on the top floor(26) paid 38k more for that unit on the 7th. So I compared mine to the exact same unit on other floors in the building. I looked up all the tax appraisals and they all appraised for the same price. So Atlanta appraised the units on the 7th floor for the same price as the penthouse units. Obviously the penthouse has better market value than a 1st floor condo. I imagine Atlanta makes millions of dollars this way by ripping off people living in highrises in Atlanta.