Alright folks, thanks to the help of @Phil@hatzopoulos and @Moriah who are up working late to support me making this thing (though they SHOULD be off having a beer!) we have some FAQ’s!
Now the question is, out of these options (which are different, but the difference is subtle)
I’m going to be the odd one out and say I like option A. It’s so clean and simple. Maybe feels a bit wide but that could be because the questions are short.
I like the options with the boxes. I think the extra “pop” that it gives the questions makes them look more like buttons and invites clicks.
As for the arrows…maybe they should start pointing down and then change to up once the answer is unfurled. This feels more intuitive to me since then the arrow is partially indicating what’s going to happen visually.
How about giving us options for both styles, boxed and unboxed? @AidanC had a good point about feeling like buttons and inviting clicks. I can see uses for both boxed and unboxed FAQs.
I actually liked A & B better with indicators on the right. The controls on the right nicely balanced out the question/answer on the left. However on desktop, A & B just felt too wide. I ended up voting C even though it felt a little too lopsided to the left.